Will's life has changed for the better. He's happily married to the talented Bonnie and on the verge of becoming a father, but his world is about to be rocked by a horrific accident. He's been preaching the word of a merciful God, but how can he do so now, when his despair sends him into a dangerous downward spiral. Jody has found newfound contentment in his relationship with Cathy, but their newfound happiness is threatened when they both face shocking announcements at work. As Mrs. C, Leonard, Jack, and Daniel gather together, both Will and Jody find themselves mired in unfamiliar emotional waters, with murder always just around the corner.